Former shadow chancellor John McDonnell has joined the voices criticizing the government’s proposed cuts to benefits, accusing ministers of lacking empathy and understanding regarding the changes. McDonnell, an independent MP after losing the Labour whip due to a previous benefits vote, expressed surprise at how poorly Labour leader Keir Starmer’s government has handled the policies leading up to these changes. Labour MPs have warned of possible resignations from the frontbench if benefits for those with disabilities are frozen. In an article for The Guardian, McDonnell highlighted the fear among disabled individuals and their caregivers caused by government announcements about potential cuts to their benefits. He criticized a “government insider” for attacking Labour MPs who voiced concerns as “pearl clutching,” suggesting a disconnect from the lessons of past policy mistakes. The upcoming changes, set to be detailed in a green paper with Chancellor Rachel Reeves presenting the spring statement on March 26, may face stronger resistance than initial changes to the winter fuel allowance. This unrest reflects early challenges faced by Tony Blair’s Labour government in 1997 over benefit cuts. McDonnell, one of seven Labour MPs stripped of the whip last July for supporting the removal of the two-child benefit cap, is among three leftists in the party yet to regain their voting rights. He critiques the government’s rigid stance on taxes and benefit cuts, advocating instead for a more flexible economic approach and a commitment to have the wealthy contribute more. Starmer’s team counters that the inheritance of an inefficient system necessitates reform to support those capable of working while safeguarding those who are not, aiming to place welfare spending on a more sustainable foundation to spur economic growth.

Source: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2025/mar/15/john-mcdonnell-accuses-ministers-of-lacking-empathy-over-benefit-cuts